An archive of Hindi movie reviews and ratings from 2010 to 2020.

critic

Shubhra Gupta

Highest rating for
Lowest rating for
Number of reviews
788
Average rating
37

Order by

Date

Title

Rating

  • PM Narendra Modi

    As a bio-pic, it inhabits muddled, post-truth territory. As a hagiography though, genuflecting at the altar of the man, it’s perfect. It’s uncritical, unquestioning, high on rhetoric. And there’s nothing accidental about it.

    39

    May 2019
  • PK

    What you need to re-purpose these themes is nuance, which, after a point, goes missing. This is where the Hirani magic recedes, and the film becomes commonplace.

    49

    Dec 2014
  • Piku

    ...sparks in moments, and I threw my head back and guffawed in a few. But the rest of it stays only mildly amusing. I wanted more motion in these motions.

    49

    May 2015
  • Phoonk 2

    ...manages to startle and scare in a few places, even if a few scenes look filched from a couple of Japanese horror films, once in a while. Can’t ask for more, not from RGV’s brand of horror.

    39

    Apr 2010
  • Phhir

    ...a 'punarjanam' film, featuring a disappearing wife, a distraught husband, and a smashing medium, and how everything falls into place right towards the end.

    29

    Aug 2011
  • Pati Patni Aur Woh

    Our ‘pati’ may have redeemed himself, and the ‘patni’ and ‘woh’ may have lifted the film somewhat, but to wish for good taste in a comedy dealing with straying husbands and wives-and-other-women-in-holding patterns is no laughing matter.

    39

    Dec 2019
  • Parmanu

    You will get the money shot of Abraham and co walking in slo-mo to swelling background music, enveloped in a comic book feel. You will not get crucial nuance and detail, essential requirements for a film to be to taken seriously.

    29

    May 2018
  • Pari

    ...the film is so poorly-written, and so scatter-brained that nothing can rescue it, not even a leading lady who is determined to do something different with her producing heft.

    19

    Mar 2018
  • Pankh

    The execution lets down the film, peppered by gratuitously grungy dialogue ( a liberal use of the `f’ word is just the start of it; all kinds of invective jostle for attention, especially because they are blipped out), and a series of unlovely people.

    19

    Apr 2010