An archive of Hindi movie reviews and ratings from 2010 to 2020.

critic

Saibal Chatterjee

Highest rating for

PK

99

Lowest rating for
Number of reviews
484
Average rating
48

Order by

Date

Title

Rating

  • Mohenjo Daro

    ...is stuck in the past and not just in terms of its substance. What the film clearly says is that both director Gowariker and Hrithik need to move on and reinvent themselves.

    39

    Aug 2016
  • Jalebi

    ...undermined considerably by the erratic quality of the acting from a cast led by two first-timers, Varun Mitra and Digangana Suryavanshi, and a still-raw Rhea Chakraborty.

    39

    Oct 2018
  • One By Two

    There is no dearth of perspiration in screenwriter Devika Bhagat’s directorial debut. She packs quite a lot into the film. Yet it feels wafer-thin.

    39

    Jan 2014
  • Noor

    ...is as appetizing as a flat beer. Whatever little effervescence it has is only window dressing.

    39

    Apr 2017
  • Dhadak

    The film saunters rather than sprints. In Sairat, that strategy clicked famously because that film had its heart in the right place. Dhadak doesn't. The result is a grind that pretty frames and fresh faces cannot mitigate.

    39

    Jul 2018
  • Super 30

    ...it tells a true story but it never rings true. Nothing in the film is less convincing than the lead performance. The idea to bronze up Hrithik Roshan so that he can impersonate Anand Kumar is anything but super: it is a formula that equals zero.

    39

    Jul 2019
  • Shakeela

    ...it ties itself up in knots in trying to get the point across. Neither Richa Chadha nor Pankaj Tripathi can clean up the dreary mess.

    39

    Dec 2020
  • Roy

    A film lavished with dollops of visual style and aural sophistication, Roy would have been a runaway cinematic delight if only its makers had coupled its impressive surface gloss with a modicum of substance.

    39

    Feb 2015
  • Panipat

    It will take three hours of your life and a whole lot of patience to sit through this laboured film. Think twice.

    39

    Dec 2019
  • Radhe

    The film dumps a whole lot of dross on us, albeit with a certain degree of surface gloss.

    39

    May 2021
  • Saheb Biwi Aur Gangster 3

    Pretty much like the political prowess that the film's fading, flailing feudal figures and their cohorts exercise, the potential of the premise to deliver surprises has, on the evidence of this outing, waned significantly.

    39

    Jul 2018
  • Rowdy Rathore

    Riddled with an array of loud, lame and specious contrivances, Rowdy Rathore plays out pretty much like a comic-book fantasy rendered in the form of a live-action film.

    39

    Jun 2012
  • Made In China

    The film isn't happy being just a comedy. It arrogates to itself a serious, larger purpose and takes a shot at earnest drama centred on performance anxiety. When sex and guilt go hand in hand, the film tells us, quacks and charlatans have a field day. On paper, the notion is great. On the screen, the result isn't.

    39

    Oct 2019
  • Lekar Hum Deewana Dil

    A tiresome tale of a pair of barely-out-of-their-teens lovers who elope before they are ready for the resultant ordeal, Lekar Hum Deewana Dil is a runaway mess.

    39

    Jul 2014
  • Anaarkali Of Aarah

    ..is the kind of film that you want to applaud, especially on account of the concerns that it articulates. But it leaves you deeply dissatisfied. It could have done with much more passion and flair. It is worse than a misfire. It doesn't fire at all despite the magnificently full-blooded pivotal performance from Swara Bhaskar.

    39

    Mar 2017
  • 102 Not Out

    This is patchy fare that is only mildly diverting despite the best efforts of two veteran actors at the top of their game.

    39

    May 2018
  • Gunday

    The eye candy on liberal display in Gunday isn’t buttressed with enough narrative energy. It really is difficult to keep a two-and-a-half-hour film from losing its wheels when its engine room is bereft of the propellant of genuine inspiration.

    39

    Feb 2014
  • Bang Bang!

    ...is strictly for Hrithik Roshan fans and for those that do not want an action flick to be anything more than just that.

    39

    Oct 2014
  • One Night Stand

    No matter how hard the director tries to liven up the proceedings, the absence of genuine substance prevents One Night Stand from rising above the irretrievably banal.

    39

    May 2016
  • Bodyguard

    ...if you value the mop on your scalp and the grey cells in your head and want to guard yourself against this potentially mind-numbing body blow, give it a miss.

    39

    Sep 2011
  • Sarbjit

    ...is a film trapped in no man's land. Based on a newsy real-life story, it takes cavalier liberties with reality. The result is a disappointment of monumental proportions.

    39

    May 2016
  • Mubarakan

    The rigmarole is enjoyable up to a point but once the idiocy quotient peaks, the overlong Mubarakan goes somewhat haywire. Yet, if it isn't as insufferable as other average Bollywood romantic comedies, a part of the credit goes to the actors.

    39

    Jul 2017