An archive of Hindi movie reviews and ratings from 2010 to 2020.

critic

Saibal Chatterjee

Highest rating for

PK

99

Lowest rating for
Number of reviews
484
Average rating
48

Order by

Date

Title

Rating

  • Maximum

    ...is a case of too much blood and blabber being wasted on a tale that has been flogged to death to such an extent that it is probably now a veritable carcass rotting in the Bollywood sun. No amount of social and political layering can dispel the rancid odour.

    49

    Jun 2012
  • Maximum

    ...lacks the nuanced detailing and the urgent pacing that should have automatically sprung from a theme yanked out of the internal files of a highly politicised police force.

    49

    Jun 2012
  • Matru Ki Bijlee Ka Mandola

    Few filmmakers in Mumbai engage with ideas and issues of contemporary relevance as felicitously as Bhardwaj. He might have fallen short this time around, but even when he is not at his best, he is infinitely better than most in the business. A director who does not fear failure merits our support.

    59

    Jan 2013
  • Mary Kom

    The obviously questionable casting of Priyanka Chopra as the lead actress and the choice of the principal shooting locations are the least of the numerous glaring problems that mar first-time director Omung Kumar’s well-intentioned but excessively effusive Mary Kom.

    49

    Sep 2014
  • Marjaavaan

    ...which is anything but a film to die for, writer-director Milap Milan Zaveri whips up a stale masala concoction that transports the audience right back to a Bollywood era gone by.

    19

    Nov 2019
  • Mardaani 2

    ...thanks to the solidity that the lead actress lends the film and the support she receives from the antagonist, Mardaani 2 is never less than riveting.

    59

    Dec 2019
  • Mardaani

    Director Sarkar receives high quality assistance from his principal technicians, who combine to keep Mardaani simple and focused on its clearly delineated plot all the way through.

    59

    Aug 2014
  • Mantostaan

    The effort of actor-writer-director Rahat Kazmi is, therefore, irrefutably pertinent and praiseworthy. The result, alas, is uneven. Mantostaan is devoid of the gut-wrenching punch that Manto's seething pen could deliver at will.

    49

    May 2017
  • Manto

    ...is a highly watchable, immediately thought-provoking cinematic work that does not have to deliver sledgehammer blows quite in the manner of Manto's more confrontational stories.

    79

    Sep 2018
  • Manmarziyaan

    ...laced with humour and warmth, is a love story with flashes - only flashes, not a sustained flow - of inspiration.

    59

    Sep 2018
  • Manjhi

    A lighter touch might have made Manjhi - The Mountain Man a markedly more convincing biopic.

    59

    Aug 2015
  • Manikarnika

    ...is agonizingly soulless. Platitudes piled upon synthetic platitudes do not add up to great cinema, especially when none of the film's war cries delivers any bang for its buck.

    19

    Jan 2019
  • Malang

    If you are seeking manic, mesmeric madness, Malang certainly isn't the film for you. But it might just live up to modest expectations.

    39

    Feb 2020
  • Malaal

    ...would have left as with no regrets whatever if only it had the courage to go all out to stress upon the power of love to surmount divisive forces at play in Mumbai and elsewhere. It abandons that topical concern and settles for a construct that drifts towards a tame, sanitized finish.

    49

    Jul 2019
  • Made In China

    The film isn't happy being just a comedy. It arrogates to itself a serious, larger purpose and takes a shot at earnest drama centred on performance anxiety. When sex and guilt go hand in hand, the film tells us, quacks and charlatans have a field day. On paper, the notion is great. On the screen, the result isn't.

    39

    Oct 2019
  • Madaari

    ... makes the right noises about the state of the nation and its people owing to the machinations of avaricious and insensitive politicians and crony contractors. However, the methods that the film uses in order to do so are rather fanciful, if not outright harebrained.

    49

    Jul 2016
  • Maatr

    Subtleties and nuances are obviously beyond Maatr. It deals solely in broad strokes. No matter how much slack you are willing to cut this film, it will still need some more in order to have its glaring gaps glossed over.

    29

    Apr 2017
  • M.S. Dhoni

    Instead of delving into the complexities of an international sporting career with its share of controversy, the patchy script glosses over the grey areas and concentrates squarely on lionizing Dhoni as a model sportsman.

    39

    Sep 2016