critic

Saibal Chatterjee

Highest rating for

PK

99

Lowest rating for
Number of reviews
477
Average rating
48

Order by

Date

Title

Rating

  • Kaagaz

    The lead actor has to carry the weight of the entire film on his shoulders. He does so gamely, occasionally allowing his usual understated style to make way for a more demonstrative mode of acting.

    59

    Jan 2021
  • Tribhanga

    ...a genteel, appropriately unfussy ode to women who are unapologetic about what they want, merits three cheers - and more.

    69

    Jan 2021
  • Shakeela

    ...it ties itself up in knots in trying to get the point across. Neither Richa Chadha nor Pankaj Tripathi can clean up the dreary mess.

    39

    Dec 2020
  • Coolie No.1

    ...does not take into account that the world has changed since the David Dhawan-Govinda combo churned out hit after hit with their mad capers. The formula that yielded dividends all those years ago no longer does.

    19

    Dec 2020
  • AK vs AK

    ...is a wild, wacky shot in the dark. It could have been a disaster had the brains behind it did not know what they were up against. That certainly isn't the case. The film's self-awareness borders on the staggering.

    69

    Dec 2020
  • Angrezi Medium

    ...the screenplay, credited to four writers (too many cooks...?), muddles things up, which is more frequently than is good for the film, it definitely isn't good news, no matter what medium one chooses to deliver it in.

    39

    Mar 2020
  • Kaamyaab

    The screenplay is insightful, if not blindingly revelatory. And some of the directorial sleights are commendably in tune with the demands of the material...

    59

    Mar 2020
  • Shubh Mangal Zyada Saavdhan

    The film may be erratic in parts, but its entertainment quotient is delightfully high for a film tackling a clash between conservatism and freedom, between tradition and modernity.

    49

    Feb 2020
  • Bhoot – Part One

    Only the very, very faint-hearted will find its jump scares worth the din that surrounds them. For the rest, Bhoot: Part One is akin to a ride on a stranded ship. You start at point A and end at point A and, what's worse, with a headache you could have done without.

    29

    Feb 2020
  • Love Aaj Kal

    ...is an audacious, if flawed, ode to love as a quest for happiness and self-realization that often triggers conflicting emotions and unsettling impulses but never fails to enrich the soul.

    59

    Feb 2020
  • Shikara

    ...is evasive on many crucial counts, but, judged on purely cinematic parameters, its strengths are noteworthy.

    49

    Feb 2020
  • Malang

    If you are seeking manic, mesmeric madness, Malang certainly isn't the film for you. But it might just live up to modest expectations.

    39

    Feb 2020
  • Street Dancer 3D

    It is an edifice built on a weak foundation: yes, a mound of rubble is what Street Dancer 3D as it collapses under its own weight. It whips up, in an unseemly fit of frenzy, a purported celebration of dance. Cinema is given short shrift in the bargain.

    29

    Jan 2020
  • Tanhaji

    ...is impressively mounted and the climactic sequences are first-rate. But too much artifice and too little authenticity is the film's bane.

    49

    Jan 2020
  • Chhapaak

    ...has several parts that are delicately crafted. But the aggregation of the elements that constitute film does not somehow yield something greater than the sum of the parts. Nonetheless the parts that work do make Chhapaak essential viewing.

    59

    Jan 2020
  • Good Newwz

    ...the complexity and depth inherent in the principal plot point remain beyond the ken of a screenplay that thrives on broad strokes.

    39

    Dec 2019
  • Dabangg 3

    ...is an all too formulaic one-way street that holds no surprises at all. It goes nowhere we haven't been before.

    29

    Dec 2019
  • Mardaani 2

    ...thanks to the solidity that the lead actress lends the film and the support she receives from the antagonist, Mardaani 2 is never less than riveting.

    59

    Dec 2019
  • Panipat

    It will take three hours of your life and a whole lot of patience to sit through this laboured film. Think twice.

    39

    Dec 2019
  • Pati Patni Aur Woh

    This iteration of Pati Patni Aur Woh manages to convey two truths: one, Bollywood's fictional heroines have evolved much faster than their male counterparts and two, film comedies that Mumbai churns out these days are no patch on the ones that the industry produced in earlier decades.

    49

    Dec 2019
  • Pagalpanti

    ...does deliver something akin to the madhouse that it promises but its loony-bin approach to hilarity is too dated to be effective.

    19

    Nov 2019