An archive of Hindi movie reviews and ratings from 2010 to 2020.

critic

Saibal Chatterjee

Highest rating for

PK

99

Lowest rating for
Number of reviews
484
Average rating
48

Order by

Date

Title

Rating

  • Ek Paheli Leela

    The painfully pointless Ek Paheli Leela is a full-blown cinematic conundrum whose depth is inversely proportional to the geneorus decolletage that is on show.

    19

    Apr 2015
  • Chitkabrey

    Chitkabrey, which redefines cock-and-bull with gay abandon, is quite a test. Go for it only if you are a sucker for tedium.

    19

    Aug 2011
  • Manikarnika

    ...is agonizingly soulless. Platitudes piled upon synthetic platitudes do not add up to great cinema, especially when none of the film's war cries delivers any bang for its buck.

    19

    Jan 2019
  • Chalk N Duster

    For intention, Chalk N Duster might get full marks, but the execution is so hopelessly ham-fisted that the film can only be described as an absolute botch-up.

    19

    Jan 2016
  • Housefull 4

    Only the very-easy-to-amuse moviegoers will find it funny enough to engage with its crazy, crass convolutions.

    19

    Oct 2019
  • Jabariya Jodi

    ...a film that appears to have been made under duress by a group of people playing blind man's buff, is a big splotch of utter nonsense.

    19

    Aug 2019
  • Joker

    ...is a crude joke of a film that will leave you in tears unless you have a stomach strong enough to digest such unmitigated junk.

    19

    Aug 2012
  • Calendar Girls

    Slapdash and sanctimonious, Calendar Girls is a stunner, but for all the wrong reasons. It is stunning in its sheer stupidity.

    19

    Sep 2015
  • Notebook

    Can picture-postcard images paper over misshapen pockmarks left on a film by a pair of rough-on-the-edges new actors finding their tentative way through a sloppy screenplay and going around in circles? If Notebook, Nitin 'Filmistaan' Kakkar's third film, is anything to go by, the answer is a big, resounding no.

    19

    Mar 2019
  • Dirty Politics

    ...a messy affair that reeks of all-round mediocrity despite the presence in the cast of actors of the calibre of Om Puri and Naseeruddin Shah.

    19

    Mar 2015
  • Zila Ghaziabad

    The film unleashes such a merciless, ceaseless and mindless onslaught on the senses and the eardrums that it could actually put the assault rifles of the most trigger-happy of crime lords in the shade.

    19

    Feb 2013
  • Marjaavaan

    ...which is anything but a film to die for, writer-director Milap Milan Zaveri whips up a stale masala concoction that transports the audience right back to a Bollywood era gone by.

    19

    Nov 2019
  • Gandhi To Hitler

    ...has the feel of a Z-grade quickie destined to be quickly consigned to the dustbins of movie history. The concept is hare-brained and the execution ham-handed and that’s putting it mildly.

    19

    Jul 2011
  • Judwaa 2

    ...might work for those that don't mind being sold old trash in a new, garishly painted sack. For all others, it would be akin to being strapped to a seat in a torture chamber.

    19

    Sep 2017
  • Total Dhamaal

    ...is a great leveller - it reduces all of us, critics included, to dunces, some willing and some not-so-willing. But that would be only if you go anywhere near it. The choice is yours.

    19

    Feb 2019
  • Humshakals

    Even by the pitiable cinematic standards that the director has so defiantly set for himself, Humshakals is the very pits. It scrapes the bottom of a barrel that seems to have no bottom at all.

    09

    Jun 2014