-
My Birthday Song
Critic reviews and ratings
-
...comes across as an honest effort and a huge relief for movie enthusiasts.
-
...is a 96 minutes of dizzying, haunting and brave attempt by producer Sanjay Suri and Samir Soni.
-
It’s not a perfect film, but there’s enough to merit a single watch.
-
...a complex story such as this one needs an experienced filmmaker. Also, the fact that the story is layered and there are multiple timelines running through the film, the treatment could have been slicker.
-
Some spit and polish and this could have been a rare good Hindi thriller.
-
While the objective of psychological thrillers may vary, a reliable yardstick would be its ability to leave one unsettled. My Birthday Song hopes to achieve this by leaving the audience dazed and confused. But incessant reliance on tropes and lack of focus, leaves one disinterested and bored — even before the big reveal.
-
Debutante director Samir Soni starts off with an amazing idea which is failed by its execution.
-
It's a great attempt. But the film had a long way to go on script level before it became awesome.
-
The plotting and the treatment is far too inept to create a solid psychological thriller out of this looping-upon-itself story, whose big reveal is too brief, too late.
-
...has just about enough meat for a short fictional film, but even that would have had to have better writing and less amateurish performances to leave traces.
-
This birthday song goes flat too soon to sustain interest.
-
...is needlessly convoluted and so annoyingly pretentious that you want the whole thing to be bleeped out of your memory.
Best and worst reviewed movies (Min. 5 reviews)
Best
-
Worst
-
Best
-
Worst
-
Best
-
Worst
-
Best
-
Worst
-
Best
-
Worst
-
Best